This message was deleted.
# generals
sparse-intern-71089
03/15/2023, 1:33 PMThis message was deleted.
a
acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 1:42 PMI figured it out. It's the security group id. The provider id from the documentation confused me. Maybe it can be updated to
c
calm-cat-43230
03/15/2023, 2:14 PMYou’re right, the documentation could probably be a bit clearer on what “provider ID” really is. There’s oblique reference to this in https://www.pulumi.com/docs/intro/concepts/resources/names/#resource-names (as the physical name), and further clarification in https://www.pulumi.com/docs/intro/concepts/resources/get/, but the term “provider ID” isn’t defined anywhere (or, IIRC, used entirely consistently).
👍 1
a
acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 2:15 PMThank you
acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 2:25 PMDo you know why Pulumi decided to make resource_name, id mandatory when we can use tags when doing a SecurityGroup.get()? We're using terraform data and we only supply tags to find the resource property like id, arn, etc.
c
calm-cat-43230
03/15/2023, 2:28 PMAre you looking for this maybe? https://www.pulumi.com/registry/packages/aws/api-docs/ec2/getsecuritygroups/ It’s an
ec2a
acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 2:29 PMThis is my code. I'll check your link now
Copy code
# Retrieve the security group object by name
existing_security_group = aws.ec2.SecurityGroup.get(
resource_name=existing_security_group_name,
id="sg-aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa",
tags={"name": existing_security_group_name},
)acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 2:29 PMyeah, looks like that's what I want
acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 2:30 PMShould I stop using the code I pasted?
acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 2:38 PMI'm trying to reference my_sg inside aws.ec2.Instance but I'm getting an error referencing it with
my_sg.id Copy code
my_sg = aws.ec2.get_security_groups(tags={
"name": "myhttp-sg",
})
instance = aws.ec2.Instance(
resource_name="my-instance",
instance_type="t2.micro",
ami="ami-1111111111111",
vpc_security_group_ids=[my_sg.id],
tags=tags
) Copy code
error: 1 error occurred:
* creating EC2 Instance: InvalidParameterValue: Value () for parameter groupId is invalid. The value cannot be empty
status code: 400, request id: 9f7a42d7-f64b-376a-8e10-bde2445d4770acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 2:45 PMI'm good. I got it working. I had to use ids property and set index to zero
c
calm-cat-43230
03/15/2023, 3:51 PMYes, it’s a list, so there’s a need to encode the assumption that it should only ever match one resource in your case (you may indeed want some sort of code to check for that), or you could just attach all SGs that you get back (which is more generalized, but may swallow a misconfiguration if you will never be needing that in your use case).
👍 1
a
acceptable-plumber-31485
03/15/2023, 4:00 PMYep, was thinking about that too. Thank you.
🙂 1
s
stocky-restaurant-98004
03/15/2023, 6:51 PMDidn't read the whole thread, but this is a common problem point of confusion. The ID is always the same as the value for
import👍 2
🙏 1
132 Views