This message was deleted.

I think you should be able to pass

resource_name

as a param to do that

that's not getting rid of the hex suffix 😞

cs.ManagedCluster(
            resource_name='aks',
            ...

on azure portal: aks566fe557

ok @tall-librarian-49374 any thoughts on overwriting the custom naming?

It must have something to do with

resource_name

parameter vs.

resource_name

property of the resource in Python…

Works, thanks! If I provide

protect=True

and

delete_before_replace=True

(as I should, I believe, when overriding autonaming?), I expect Pulumi to block any updates to that resource if that update requires replacement - and thus, deletion in this case. Is my intuition correct?

delete_before_replace

is applies automatically if you switch off auto-naming. and yes, protect=true should prevent any deletion.

not sure I understand what you mean. could you please suggest edits to this snippet?

cs.ManagedCluster(
        resource_name=resource_name,
        resource_name_=resource_name,  # Overrides auto-naming
        resource_group_name=resource_group.name,
        ...

sorry, I think I’m dreaming a feature which doesn’t exist yet

delete_before_replace

 is applies automatically if you switch off auto-naming

quoting https://www.pulumi.com/docs/intro/concepts/resources/#autonaming

Overriding auto-naming makes your project susceptible to naming collisions. As a result, for resources that may need to be replaced, you should specify 

deleteBeforeReplace: true

 in the resource’s options. This option ensures that old resources are deleted before new ones are created, which will prevent those collisions.

so which is it?

I think Azure-Native is smart here, but feel free to try with some temporary resource

thanks, makes sense. already including it, just wanted to know the consequences of accidental omission. so, with autonaming overridden and even with an explicit

delete_before_replace=True

,

p state unprotect --all -y && p up -r --show-replacement-steps -y

results in:

azure-native:containerservice:ManagedCluster (aks):
    error: cannot create already existing resource '/subscriptions/****/resourceGroups/****/providers/Microsoft.ContainerService/managedClusters/****-aks'

I was expecting this combination of config and commands to let pulumi delete and recreate the resource if necessary. where could i be going wrong?