This message was deleted.

sparse-intern-71089

08/31/2021, 7:03 PM

This message was deleted.

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 7:26 PM

did you make a code change?

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 7:31 PM

Yes I did introduce several changes.

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 7:34 PM

can you share your code and wht you changed? some options/parameters are immutable

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 7:37 PM

Unfortunately I did not track what was changed, this is PoC. I'm going to start again with a blank slate and see if I can reproduce the issue just by changing the value of the image reference.

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 8:42 PM

So I did restart from scratch, using the image reference as a string in the configuration and got the very same error message after changing its value in the configuration:

var dataDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Disk($"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}-datadisk", new AzureNative.Compute.DiskArgs{

CreationData = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.CreationDataArgs

CreateOption = "Empty",

},

DiskSizeGB = 100,

ResourceGroupName = org.ResourceGroupName

});

var vm = new  AzureNative.Compute.VirtualMachine($"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}",

new AzureNative.Compute.VirtualMachineArgs

ResourceGroupName = org.ResourceGroupName,

HardwareProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.HardwareProfileArgs

VmSize = "Standard_A1_v2",

},

Location = regionname,

NetworkProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.NetworkProfileArgs

NetworkInterfaces = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.NetworkInterfaceReferenceArgs

Id =  networkInterface.Id,

Primary = true,

},

},

OsProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.OSProfileArgs

AdminPassword = "xxxxxxxxxxxx",

AdminUsername = "xxxxxxxxxxxx",

ComputerName = $"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}",

WindowsConfiguration = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.WindowsConfigurationArgs

EnableAutomaticUpdates = true,

PatchSettings = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.PatchSettingsArgs

AssessmentMode = "ImageDefault",

},

ProvisionVMAgent = true,

},

},

StorageProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.StorageProfileArgs

ImageReference = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.ImageReferenceArgs

Id = imageId,

},

OsDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.OSDiskArgs

Caching = AzureNative.Compute.CachingTypes.ReadWrite,

CreateOption = AzureNative.Compute.DiskCreateOptionTypes.FromImage,

ManagedDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.ManagedDiskParametersArgs

StorageAccountType = "Standard_LRS",

},

_//Name = $"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}-osdisk",_

},

DataDisks = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.DataDiskArgs

Caching = AzureNative.Compute.CachingTypes.ReadWrite,

CreateOption = AzureNative.Compute.DiskCreateOptionTypes.Attach,

ManagedDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.ManagedDiskParametersArgs

StorageAccountType = "Standard_LRS",

Id = dataDisk.Id

},

DiskSizeGB = 100,

Lun = 1,

},

});

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 8:44 PM

that's kinda hard to read sorry, can you wrap the code in 3 backticks each side

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 8:44 PM

```

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 8:44 PM

```

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 8:46 PM

My bad

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 8:46 PM

Copy code

var dataDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Disk($"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}-datadisk", new AzureNative.Compute.DiskArgs{
                CreationData = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.CreationDataArgs
                {
                    CreateOption = "Empty",
                },
                DiskSizeGB = 100,
                ResourceGroupName = org.ResourceGroupName
            });
            
            var vm = new  AzureNative.Compute.VirtualMachine($"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}",
                new AzureNative.Compute.VirtualMachineArgs
                {
                    ResourceGroupName = org.ResourceGroupName,
                    HardwareProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.HardwareProfileArgs
                    {
                        VmSize = "Standard_A1_v2",
                    },
                    Location = regionname,
                    NetworkProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.NetworkProfileArgs
                    {
                        
                        NetworkInterfaces = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.NetworkInterfaceReferenceArgs
                        {
                            Id =  networkInterface.Id,
                            Primary = true,
                        },
                    },
                    OsProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.OSProfileArgs
                    {
                        AdminPassword = "xxxxxxxxxxxx",
                        AdminUsername = "xxxxxxxxxxxx",
                        ComputerName = $"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}",
                        WindowsConfiguration = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.WindowsConfigurationArgs
                        {
                            EnableAutomaticUpdates = true,
                            PatchSettings = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.PatchSettingsArgs
                            {
                                AssessmentMode = "ImageDefault",
                            },
                            ProvisionVMAgent = true,
                        },
                    },
                    StorageProfile = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.StorageProfileArgs
                    {
                        ImageReference = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.ImageReferenceArgs
                        {
                            Id = imageId,
                        },
                        OsDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.OSDiskArgs
                        {
                            Caching = AzureNative.Compute.CachingTypes.ReadWrite,
                            CreateOption = AzureNative.Compute.DiskCreateOptionTypes.FromImage,
                            ManagedDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.ManagedDiskParametersArgs
                            {
                                StorageAccountType = "Standard_LRS",
                            },
                            //Name = $"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}-osdisk",
                        },
                        DataDisks = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.DataDiskArgs
                        {
                            Caching = AzureNative.Compute.CachingTypes.ReadWrite,
                            CreateOption = AzureNative.Compute.DiskCreateOptionTypes.Attach,
                            ManagedDisk = new AzureNative.Compute.Inputs.ManagedDiskParametersArgs
                            {
                                StorageAccountType = "Standard_LRS",
                                Id = dataDisk.Id
                            },
                            DiskSizeGB = 100,
                            Lun = 1,
                        }
                    },
                });

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 8:48 PM

with

Copy code

var imageId = new Pulumi.Config().Require("imageId");

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 8:49 PM

are you using auto naming? it looks like that value is immutable

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 8:51 PM

I do

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 8:56 PM

This is probably a silly question, but how do I workaround that ? I mean how can I update a virtual machine when there is a new image that I want to push ?

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 8:58 PM

can you show me the diff when you go to update? if you're using autonaming, it should replace the VM with a new VM using the new image ID

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 9:01 PM

Copy code

Type                                    Name                  Plan       Info
pulumi:pulumi:Stack                     snqacloud-csharp-dev
~   └─ azure-native:compute:VirtualMachine  org1-p1-n1            update     [diff: ~storageProfile]

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 9:05 PM

I can definitely see the suffix for the virtual machine resource name in Azure portal.

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 9:42 PM

yeah I'm thinking this might be a bug at this point, would you mind filing an issue in github.com/pulumi/azure-native

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 9:42 PM

it should do a replace, not an update

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 9:45 PM

Okay thank you ! Is there anything else I can do to confirm this is a bug and rule out that I'm doing soething wrong ?

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 10:23 PM

which version of the provider are you using?

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 10:24 PM

@numerous-action-56322 I think it's this property:

Copy code

ComputerName = $"{orgname}-{gridname}-n{i+1}",

billowy-army-68599

08/31/2021, 10:24 PM

can you try removing it?

numerous-action-56322

08/31/2021, 11:15 PM

Thanks for the thorough follow up. I’ll do it as soon as I get a chance and keep you informed on the outcome.

numerous-action-56322

09/01/2021, 1:36 AM

I'm afraid I cannot remove it, it is a required ppty.

numerous-action-56322

09/01/2021, 1:37 AM

error: Code="InvalidParameter" Message="Required parameter 'computerName' is missing (null)." Target="computerName"

billowy-army-68599

09/01/2021, 3:01 AM

Definitely a bug, please file an issue

numerous-action-56322

09/01/2021, 1:09 PM

Will do. Thanks

billowy-army-68599

09/01/2021, 3:01 PM

hey @numerous-action-56322 did you manage to get an issue opened here?

numerous-action-56322

09/01/2021, 3:06 PM

Hi @billowy-army-68599 , https://github.com/pulumi/pulumi-azure-native/issues/1117

billowy-army-68599

09/01/2021, 3:24 PM

@numerous-action-56322 I discussed privately with Mikhail, to get you unblocked you can use `replaceOnChanges`: https://www.pulumi.com/docs/intro/concepts/resources/#replaceonchanges

numerous-action-56322

09/01/2021, 3:26 PM

@billowy-army-68599 Thanks again.

numerous-action-56322

09/01/2021, 7:29 PM

@billowy-army-68599 I've been trying to implement the provided workaround, however updates are still failing with the very same error message, as if the additional CustomResourceOptions passed as a third argument were ineffective

Copy code

new CustomResourceOptions{
                    ReplaceOnChanges =new List<string>(new string[] {"imageReference.id"} ),
                }

I even tried to relax the property path by using just "imageReference" and the the joker "*" . Any idea ? Btw, I could not reuse the C# sample from the documentation since I don't know what the var

pulumi

stands for. Could this be the reason why my updates are still not working ? For your convenience, here's the sample provided in the documentation , the var `pulumi`appears on the last line only.

Copy code

var widget = new Pulumi.Kubernetes.ApiExtensions.CustomResource("widget", new WidgetArgs
{
    Spec = new WidgetSpecArgs
    {
        Input = "something",
    }
}, pulumi.ReplaceOnChanges([]string{"spec.input"}));

755 Views

Open in Slack

Previous Next

Pulumi Community

No matter how you like to participate in developer communities, Pulumi wants to meet you there. If you want to meet other Pulumi users to share use-cases and best practices, contribute code or documentation, see us at an event, or just tell a story about something cool you did with Pulumi, you are part of our community.