If I change the `identifier` of a `aws rds Instance` Pulumi

Question

If I change the `identifier` of a `aws rds Instance` Pulumi thinks it needs to replace the instance This property is actually able to be changed in place

gentle-diamond-70147 · Answer

Sounds like a bug Can you open an issue at <http github com pulumi pulumi aws|github com pulumi pulumi aws>

full-dress-10026 · Answer

Done <https github com pulumi pulumi aws issues 589>

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

< full dress 10026> < gentle diamond 70147> this is not a big

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

Bug

gentle-diamond-70147 · Answer

Gah no

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

This is how the terraform provider works as well

gentle-diamond-70147 · Answer

Oh bug in terraform provider then Or is that actually not able to be updated in place

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

I don t believe so I don t believe the aws cli even allows this

full-dress-10026 · Answer

I can definitely change this via the AWS console

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

I don t believe it s possible anywhere other than there the api doesn t seem to have an operation for it

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

I made most of this terraform provider and looked at so many different ways of trying to allow it to change

full-dress-10026 · Answer

So strange Wonder how the console does this

gentle-diamond-70147 · Answer

Is it an immediate change in the console Maybe it waits for a maintenance window to make a change pure speculation

full-dress-10026 · Answer

I can select immediate or wait for maintenance window

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

Can you tag me stack72 in that issue and I can look tomorrow when I m working < full dress 10026>

full-dress-10026 · Answer

Sure

broad-dog-22463 · Answer

Thanks