Generated objects in python have unreal names this is not py

Question

Generated objects in python have unreal names this is not pythonic it looks like Java or C at best disappointed ```ServiceSourceConfigurationAuthenticationConfigurationArgs``` Is there any chance to remedy this without dropping into dictionaries PEP8 python line length suggest 79 characters the name above is 57

red-match-15116 · Answer

What s your suggestion

great-sunset-355 · Answer

first at least drop the suffix `Args` if possible because it s not consistent with docs Then make use of namespaces as Zen of python says I wonder how it would look if we could break it down into packages ```import this The Zen of Python by Tim Peters Beautiful is better than ugly Explicit is better than implicit Simple is better than complex Complex is better than complicated Flat is better than nested Sparse is better than dense Readability counts Special cases aren t special enough to break the rules Although practicality beats purity Errors should never pass silently Unless explicitly silenced In the face of ambiguity refuse the temptation to guess There should be one and preferably only one obvious way to do it ``` Let s say I have `ServiceSourceConfiguration`

great-sunset-355 · Answer

Found another one with 84 smile ServiceSourceConfigurationCodeRepositoryCodeConfigurationCodeConfigurationValuesArgs

red-match-15116 · Answer

FWIW you don t need to use the `Args` classes They are provided as a convenience and an alternative to using keyword args We added them recently as a user request so that args could be passed around separately from the resources That being said this is not about python but how the resources are structured in the encapsulating providers Anyway welcome to our world let us know if you figure out how to do it in a way that you find more appealing and we ll consider it slightly smiling face

great-sunset-355 · Answer

I took a lot of inspiration from CDK to me it seems they are on the right track

great-sunset-355 · Answer

Instead of this ```authentication configuration= connection arn aws apprunner connection example arn ``` I d rather ```authentication configuration=AuthenticationConfiguration connection arn= asdf ``` In case this would be a conflict then use namespace gt sub package

great-sunset-355 · Answer

then user has choice whether to use full name from the parent or import as deeply as needed eg ```from pulumi aws apprunner service import AuthenticationConfiguration```

red-match-15116 · Answer

gt I d rather ```authentication configuration=AuthenticationConfiguration connection arn= asdf ``` This is how it currently works

great-sunset-355 · Answer

no current Class name is `ServiceSourceConfigurationAuthenticationConfiguration` it should be at least 2 or 3 nested packages in order to prevent namespace conflicts not just concacetnating names

great-sunset-355 · Answer

On top of that word `Configuration` repeats in the name twice In this class even three times ```ServiceSourceConfigurationCodeRepositoryCodeConfigurationCodeConfiguration```

great-sunset-355 · Answer

names like this does not make anything easier to read it s the exact opposite

red-match-15116 · Answer

It s unlikely that we will take a massive breaking change like this but you are welcome to open an issue and summarize your suggestion