I am trying to create an

aws.cloudwatch.MetricAlarm

however i cant see how to get the filterId from

aws.s3.BucketMetric

snip:

const bucket = new aws.s3.BucketV2(
  `viz-bucket-${region}`,
  {
    bucketPrefix: `par-${region}-`,
    forceDestroy: true
  },
  {provider: PriActProviders[region]}
);

const bucketMetrics = new aws.s3.BucketMetric(
  `bucketMetrics-${region}`,
  {bucket: bucket.bucket},
  {provider: PriActProviders[region], parent: bucket}
);

// create alarm for R53 to monitor as health check
const bucketMetricAlarm = new aws.cloudwatch.MetricAlarm(
  `bucketMetricAlarm-${region}`,
  {
    comparisonOperator: 'GreaterThanOrEqualToThreshold',
    evaluationPeriods: 1,
    datapointsToAlarm: 1,
    treatMissingData: 'missing',
    metricName: '5xxErrors',
    namespace: 'AWS/S3',
    unit: 'Count',
    period: 60,
    statistic: 'Sum',
    threshold: 2,
    dimensions: {
      BucketName: bucket.bucket,
      // FilterId: ''  // ????
    },
    alarmDescription: 'This metric monitors s3 bucket Sum 5xx errors.'
  },
  {
    provider: PriActProviders[region],
    parent: bucket
  }
);

Have you tried something like a prefix?

This dimension filters metrics configurations that you specify for the request metrics on a bucket. When you create a metrics configuration, you specify a filter ID (for example, a prefix, a tag, or an access point). For more information, see Creating a metrics configuration.

my bucketMetrics does not specify a filter, however a filter Id is created that only has the criteria of entire bucket. and the alarm does not get data in cloudwatch unless a filterId is specified

have you tried

.

or

/

?

the metrics get created. i can see them in the s3 console, however the alarm wont pick up the data without the filterId, however i dont see any way to get it from the BucketMetric object

Have you tried using

bucketMetrics.filter

?

bucketMetrics.filter

is just the definition of the filter, does not give the FilterId

Ahh yes, sorry, I'm using awsx and alarms a bit differently

The alarm as is just sits in a state of "Insufficient data", however if i manually create the alarm in the cloudwatch console it wont let me not specify the filter id

If you can get it with the aws sdk, you can use

aws.sdk

directly within pulumi to get that ID until the behavior is added to the provider. Might want to open an issue for that.

to enable requests metrics you must create a filter, you can give it whatever name you want then just scope to entire bucket. in the case of the auto generated pulumi one it uses the same resource name as BucketMetric with a hash appended to it

oh, but it's different than

bucketMetric.id

?

ok, i looks likte bucketMetrics.name is being used as the filter id, let me try that

perfect!

deployment is running, will keep you posted. thank you for your help!