hey all quick question when im working with my team and we e

Question

hey all quick question when im working with my team and we each do a pulumi deployment why does the next user who deploys have to redeploy the entire stack and not only the diff

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

Hello < rough jordan 15935> is everybody on the team using the same stack Which state backend are you using our cloud service vs cloud object storage

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

cloud service

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

and also another big question is when i use api gateway AWS and deploy with a new resource the entire api gateway goes down and says unexpected token e error and cannot invoke any lambda it needs a second deployment to fix

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

Preferably post new questions as separate Slack messages That makes it easier to answer in a threaded style pray skin tone 3

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

okay

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

Regarding the state backend you and your colleagues are using our cloud service Are you using a organization account where the stack is shared If you all use e g `dev` as the stack name you each have a `dev` stack in your personal Pulumi account If you use an organization account the stack name contains the organization name e g ` lt org gt dev`

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

yes thats correct we have a pattern like that

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

when one of us deploys the other has to do a full deployment

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

With a `pattern like that` you mean that you each have a stack with the same name but each in your own personal account

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

no its in one account

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

and we create access tokens on that single account

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

and each of you have the same version of the code checked out from Git including the stack config file

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

yes that is correct we have checked in the `pulumi dev yml`file to git and pull it from VCS

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

OK what I would like you to do you run `pulumi up` and post the output in a first message here together with the output of `pulumi about` one of your colleagues also runs `pulumi up` and I also would like to see the output together with the output of `pulumi about` from their machine

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

hm sharing the content of pulumi about would be a privacy issue

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

Please review the output before pasting and remove any confidential pieces But that output usually shouldn t contain any secrets Can t do much without it though

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

sure i will have a look at that and share could you also take a look at the api gateway issue ive sent

gorgeous-country-43026 · Answer

Just jumping in now that I m at work you said no its in one account does this mean you are using a single Pulumi Cloud account OR that you are using an organization and org stacks

gorgeous-country-43026 · Answer

If first you should definitely go via org route when using Pulumi Cloud

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

we have a single pulumi cloud account

gorgeous-country-43026 · Answer

I guess Ringo can answer better but that might be one of the reasons you have problems You see with Pulumi Cloud there s transactional checks for concurrent updates done by different users and because of this I would assume that state syncing is different

gorgeous-country-43026 · Answer

It is a very good idea anyway to have separate accounts and org

gorgeous-country-43026 · Answer

Consider person leaving a company

gorgeous-country-43026 · Answer

Shared accounts are in general a bad idea

limited-rainbow-51650 · Answer

< gorgeous country 43026> on our cloud backend whether shared via a single user account or via orgs we have state locking in place to prevent concurrent updates I guess there is still something else at play here

gorgeous-country-43026 · Answer

Gotcha Still good idea to go via orgs+separate accounts route

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

hm wonder whats happening

rough-jordan-15935 · Answer

ill send over the `pulumi about` info