Hi! :wave: I'm having some issues with replacing a...
# aws
Hi! πŸ‘‹ I'm having some issues with replacing an existing aws.servicediscovery.PrivateDnsNamespace().. it's trying to delete the namespace, but there are still ECS / Fargate services running that use the old namespace (see thread for output). Seems like a bug, perhaps?
Output from `pulumi up`:
Copy code
Previewing update (dev)

View Live: <https://app.pulumi.com/sch_johwar2/redata-aws-fargate/dev/previews/805ae9ef-3aae-402e-aa38-0e3902c9cb26>

     Type                                         Name                      Plan        Info
     pulumi:pulumi:Stack                          redata-aws-fargate-dev                
 +-  β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:TaskDefinition                    airflow-web-task          replace     
 +-  β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:TaskDefinition                    airflow-scheduler-task    replace     
 +-  β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:TaskDefinition                    grafana-web-task          replace     
 +-  β”œβ”€ aws:servicediscovery:PrivateDnsNamespace  redata-sd-namespace       replace     [diff: ~name]
 ~   β”œβ”€ aws:efs:FileSystemPolicy                  redata-efs-policy         update      [diff: ~policy]
     β”œβ”€ redata:service:BackendService             airflow-scheduler                     
 +-  β”‚  β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:Service                        airflow-scheduler-svc     replace     [diff: ~name,serviceRegistries,taskDefinition]
 +-  β”‚  └─ aws:servicediscovery:Service           airflow-scheduler-sd-svc  replace     [diff: ~dnsConfig]
     β”œβ”€ redata:service:WebService                 airflow-web                           
     β”‚  └─ redata:service:BackendService          airflow-web                           
 +-  β”‚     β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:Service                     airflow-web-svc           replace     [diff: ~name,serviceRegistries,taskDefinition]
 +-  β”‚     └─ aws:servicediscovery:Service        airflow-web-sd-svc        replace     [diff: ~dnsConfig]
     β”œβ”€ redata:service:WebService                 grafana-web                           
     β”‚  └─ redata:service:BackendService          grafana-web                           
 +-  β”‚     β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:Service                     grafana-web-svc           replace     [diff: ~name,serviceRegistries,taskDefinition]
 +-  β”‚     └─ aws:servicediscovery:Service        grafana-web-sd-svc        replace     [diff: ~dnsConfig]
 +   β”œβ”€ aws:route53:Record                        airflow-postgres-cname    create      
 +   └─ aws:route53:Record                        redata-postgres-cname     create      
    + 2 to create
    ~ 1 to update
    +-10 to replace
    13 changes. 33 unchanged

Do you want to perform this update? yes
Updating (dev)

View Live: <https://app.pulumi.com/sch_johwar2/redata-aws-fargate/dev/updates/119>

     Type                                         Name                    Status                   Info
     pulumi:pulumi:Stack                          redata-aws-fargate-dev  **failed**               1 error
 +-  β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:TaskDefinition                    airflow-web-task        replaced                 
 ~   β”œβ”€ aws:efs:FileSystemPolicy                  redata-efs-policy       updated                  [diff: ~policy]
 +-  β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:TaskDefinition                    airflow-scheduler-task  replaced                 
 +-  β”œβ”€ aws:ecs:TaskDefinition                    grafana-web-task        replaced                 
 +-  └─ aws:servicediscovery:PrivateDnsNamespace  redata-sd-namespace     **replacing failed**     1 error
  pulumi:pulumi:Stack (redata-aws-fargate-dev):
    error: update failed
  aws:servicediscovery:PrivateDnsNamespace (redata-sd-namespace):
    error: deleting urn:pulumi:dev::redata-aws-fargate::aws:servicediscovery/privateDnsNamespace:PrivateDnsNamespace::redata-sd-namespace: 1 error occurred:
    	* error deleting Service Discovery Private DNS Namespace (ns-o4ilckypsuym75iu): ResourceInUse: Namespace has associated services; delete the services before deleting the namespace
    airflow-db         : "<http://airflow-postgresacfea51.co25doitymly.eu-west-1.rds.amazonaws.com:5432|airflow-postgresacfea51.co25doitymly.eu-west-1.rds.amazonaws.com:5432>"
    airflow-web-web-url: "<https://redata.blocket-insight-dev.schibsted.io/airflow>"
    grafana-web-web-url: "<https://redata.blocket-insight-dev.schibsted.io/grafana>"
    redata-db          : "<http://redata-postgres36ddbfa.co25doitymly.eu-west-1.rds.amazonaws.com:5432|redata-postgres36ddbfa.co25doitymly.eu-west-1.rds.amazonaws.com:5432>"

    ~ 1 updated
    33 unchanged

Duration: 11s
The changes I'm trying to make:
Copy code
diff --git a/deployment/pulumi_aws_fargate/__main__.py b/deployment/pulumi_aws_fargate/__main__.py
index 01fa5a3..a2ed3e4 100644
--- a/deployment/pulumi_aws_fargate/__main__.py
+++ b/deployment/pulumi_aws_fargate/__main__.py
@@ -127,6 +127,7 @@ efs = redata.fs.FileSystem("redata-efs",
 # Service Discovery for intra-cluster communication
 sd_namespace = aws.servicediscovery.PrivateDnsNamespace("redata-sd-namespace",
+    name="redata.local",
     description="Private namespace for Redata services",
@@ -194,6 +195,13 @@ for backend in ("airflow", "redata"):
+    db_cname = aws.route53.Record(f"{backend}-postgres-cname",
+        name=f"{backend}-postgres",
+        zone_id=sd_namespace.hosted_zone,
+        type='CNAME',
+        ttl=60,
+        records=[db.address],
+    )
     databases[backend] = db
     export(f"{backend}-db", db.endpoint)
Link to full version of code, before the above changes: https://github.com/redata-team/redata/pull/31
I’m a bit confused on how the replacement is happening? I don’t see the namespace in the PR you linked.
It looks like what’s checked in has β€œredata-sd-local-namespace” which is different from the diff you have above. Were you able to get this working?
Yeah, I had to add the modified namespace first, with a different name.. Then after 'pulumi up' replaced all the references, I could remove the old version.
The issue seems to be that while Pulumi does replace references in the service definitions, it's not waiting for the old tasks to be fully phased out (which takes a few minutes).
I, uh, did a lot of changes and then rebased + force pushed, so the link isn't that useful now πŸ˜…
No worries β€” just wanted to make sure you got unblocked here. Regarding the general use case, you may want to set
on the
Ahh ok, thanks! πŸ‘